COMM 380:  Media Criticism

Introduction

 

Greta Gerwig’s Little Women (2019) is a modern adaptation of Louisa May Alcott’s classic novel, bringing a fresh perspective to the story of the March sisters. Through innovative storytelling and a contemporary lens, Gerwig delivers a film that resonates with today's audience while staying faithful to the original text. By examining the film's deeper layers and societal implications, we can appreciate how Gerwig revitalizes a beloved story, making it both a tribute to Alcott’s work and a commentary on modern issues. Moreover, this analysis will explore how the film’s themes reflect ongoing conversations about gender equality and creative freedom. Ultimately, Gerwig’s Little Women offers a rich, multifaceted portrayal of the complexities women face in the past and present.

 

Imagine a world where women are confined to the domestic sphere, their dreams and ambitions overshadowed by societal expectations. Now, contrast that with Greta Gerwig's vibrant world in Little Women, where the March sisters defy these constraints and pursue their passions with unrelenting vigor. The film captures these characters' timeless struggles and triumphs, reminding us of the ongoing fight for gender equality and the importance of following one's dreams regardless of societal pressures. This dynamic portrayal challenges viewers to consider their perceptions of gender roles and ambition. Gerwig’s use of vivid cinematography and compelling performances also ensures that the story's emotional depth resonates profoundly with modern audiences. By immersing us in the lives of the March sisters, the film invites a deeper reflection on the societal progress and challenges that continue to shape women's experiences today.

 

Set during the Civil War era, the film follows the lives of four sisters—Jo, Meg, Amy, and Beth—as they navigate the complexities of growing up, pursuing their dreams, and finding their place in a world that often underestimates them. Gerwig’s directorial choices, combined with an exceptional cast, breathe new life into this timeless tale, making it both a tribute to Alcott’s work and a commentary on contemporary issues. Through non-linear storytelling and nuanced character development, Gerwig connects the past and present, showing how the challenges the March sisters face are still relevant today. The film’s layered narrative structure allows for a rich exploration of each character’s journey, highlighting the multifaceted nature of personal growth and societal expectations. Furthermore, Gerwig’s thoughtful adaptation underscores the enduring relevance of Alcott’s themes, particularly in today’s ongoing discussions about gender and identity. By interweaving these elements, the film creates a powerful dialogue between historical and contemporary perspectives.

 

Through its implicit meanings and symptomatic analysis, Greta Gerwig's Little Women not only captures the essence of Alcott's novel but also addresses modern feminist themes, highlighting the ongoing struggle for gender equality and the pursuit of personal fulfillment. This adaptation serves as a bridge between eras, emphasizing that the fight for women's rights and self-determination is as crucial now as it was during Alcott’s time. By examining the film’s intricate narrative techniques and character portrayals, we can better understand its commentary on societal norms and individual aspirations. Moreover, Gerwig’s adaptation offers a fresh lens to view the intersection of historical context and contemporary relevance. Ultimately, Little Women stands as a testament to the enduring power of storytelling in advocating for social change.

​

Supporting Information and Analysis

 

Gerwig's adaptation subtly shifts the focus from mere narrative to a deeper exploration of the character’s inner lives and societal roles. Implicitly, the film delves into artistic expression and themes of financial independence. Jo March’s (Saoirse Ronan) struggle to be recognized as a writer is a personal battle and a reflection of the broader societal constraints on women. The film emphasizes that her desire to write is intertwined with her quest for autonomy and self-identity, showcasing how personal ambition and societal roles intersect. The portrayal of Jo’s relentless pursuit of her passion, despite numerous setbacks, serves as a powerful commentary on the resilience required to overcome gendered obstacles.

​

Additionally, Gerwig’s emphasis on Jo’s internal conflicts and her interactions with her family provides a nuanced understanding of women artists' pressures. Through these elements, the film subtly critiques women's historical and ongoing marginalization in the arts. The nonlinear narrative structure employed by Gerwig allows for a more nuanced portrayal of each sister's journey, implicitly questioning the linear progression of time and growth often imposed on women's stories. This technique invites the audience to consider the various stages of womanhood and the recurring challenges women face across different periods of their lives. The film’s narrative fluidity mirrors the complexity of human experience, suggesting that personal growth and societal change are not always straightforward. Gerwig highlights the enduring relevance of the characters’ struggles by weaving together past and present, making their stories resonate with contemporary viewers. This approach also underscores the cyclical nature of societal challenges, emphasizing the need for continual progress and reflection. Ultimately, the film’s structure reinforces its themes of resilience, self-discovery, and the ongoing fight for equality.

 

Symptomatically, Little Women can be seen as a critique of 21st-century gender politics. The film's release amid the #MeToo movement and increasing discussions about women's rights and representation in media adds a layer of urgency to its themes. Gerwig uses the period setting to comment on contemporary issues, suggesting that the struggles faced by the March sisters are not relics of the past but ongoing battles. This historical and contemporary parallel highlights the persistent nature of gender inequality. The film’s depiction of Amy March’s (Florence Pugh) pragmatic approach to marriage and her recognition of its economic implications further illustrates these ongoing societal issues. Gerwig highlights these concerns and emphasizes the need for continued advocacy and awareness in addressing gender-based disparities. Additionally, the film’s exploration of financial independence and creative autonomy underscores the broader implications of these themes in today’s socio-political landscape.

 

Amy March’s speech about marriage as an economic proposition is particularly resonant in today’s climate, highlighting the financial and social pressures that still influence women’s choices. The film suggests that while the context has changed, the underlying issues of gender inequality and societal expectations remain relevant. By presenting these themes through a historical lens, Gerwig underscores the cyclical nature of these challenges, urging modern viewers to recognize and address them. This approach honors the original text and enriches the narrative by connecting it to contemporary struggles. Moreover, the film’s nuanced portrayal of these issues encourages viewers to reflect on their experiences and the broader societal context. Ultimately, Little Women serves as a poignant reminder of the progress made and the work still needed in the fight for gender equality.

 

Critical Analysis

 

Gerwig’s Little Women stands out for its critical examination of gender roles. Jo’s resistance to traditional femininity and her rejection of marriage in favor of her career underscores the film’s feminist undertones. Gerwig’s portrayal of Jo is complex; she is neither an outright rebel nor a conformist but a woman navigating her desires and societal expectations. This complexity adds depth to her character, making her relatable to modern audiences who grapple with similar issues. The film’s depiction of Jo’s struggle for artistic recognition also highlights the broader challenges women face in achieving professional success. Gerwig emphasizes the importance of personal authenticity and resilience by showcasing these multifaceted aspects of Jo's character. Furthermore, the film’s critical perspective on traditional gender roles encourages viewers to question and challenge societal norms in their own lives.

 

The film also critically examines the role of family and sisterhood in shaping the characters’ identities. Each sister’s response to their familial bonds and aspirations provides a rich tapestry of experiences, reflecting the diverse ways women negotiate their roles within the family and society. By highlighting these dynamics, Gerwig emphasizes the importance of personal ambition and supportive relationships in achieving self-fulfillment. The film’s portrayal of the sisters’ interactions underscores the significance of solidarity and mutual support in navigating societal challenges. This emphasis on collective strength and individual growth provides a powerful commentary on the interconnected nature of personal and social progress. Ultimately, Little Women offers a nuanced exploration of the interplay between individual aspirations and communal bonds, highlighting the multifaceted nature of women’s experiences.

 

Critics might argue that Gerwig’s modern touches detract from the historical authenticity of Alcott’s story. However, these contemporary elements make the adaptation powerful and relevant. Gerwig bridges the gap between past and present by blending period details with modern sensibilities, demonstrating that gender inequality and personal autonomy transcend time. This approach honors Alcott’s original work and reinvigorates it, making it accessible and engaging for today’s audience. The film’s ability to resonate with contemporary viewers underscores its enduring relevance and impact. Furthermore, Gerwig’s thoughtful integration of modern themes ensures that the adaptation remains faithful to the spirit of the original text while offering fresh insights. Ultimately, the film’s innovative approach enhances its emotional and intellectual depth, creating a compelling narrative that speaks to multiple generations.

 

Conclusion

 

Greta Gerwig’s Little Women is more than a faithful adaptation of a beloved novel; it profoundly explores gender roles, personal ambition, and the enduring struggle for equality. Through its implicit and symptomatic meanings, the film speaks to both the historical context of the March sisters and the contemporary issues women face today. By analyzing these themes, Gerwig’s Little Women emerges as a significant cultural text, urging viewers to reflect on the progress made and the work still needed in the fight for gender equality. This adaptation not only preserves the essence of Alcott’s novel but also amplifies its relevance, inspiring new generations to continue advocating for gender justice. Furthermore, the film’s innovative narrative techniques and nuanced character portrayals highlight the timeless nature of its themes, ensuring its place as a critical piece of cinematic art. Ultimately, Little Women serves as a poignant reminder of the power of storytelling in effecting social change and promoting empathy.

​

Bibliography

Dargis, Manohla. “Review: Greta Gerwig’s ‘Little Women’ Is Big on Joy.” The New York Times, 23 Dec. 2019.

​

Roeper, Richard. “Review: Greta Gerwig’s ‘Little Women’ Breathes New Life into an Old Classic.” Chicago Sun-Times, 24 Dec. 2019.

 

Kohn, Eric. “Greta Gerwig’s ‘Little Women’ Is a Rapturous Retelling of a Timeless Classic.” IndieWire, 23 Dec. 2019.

 

Debruge, Peter. “Film Review: ‘Little Women’.” Variety, 23 Dec. 2019.

 

Edelstein, David. “Greta Gerwig’s Little Women Is a Delightful, Moving Triumph.” Vulture, 24 Dec. 2019.

 

Smith, Sharon. “Revisiting Little Women: Greta Gerwig’s Feminist Adaptation.” Journal of Film and Video, vol. 72, no. 1, 2020, pp. 15-30.

 

Johnson, Emily. “Narrative Structure and Gender Politics in Gerwig’s Little Women.” Studies in Adaptation, vol. 5, no. 2, 2021, pp. 45-60.

 

Williams, Rebecca. “From Page to Screen: The Evolution of Little Women.” Adaptation Studies Quarterly, vol. 10, no. 3, 2020, pp. 78-95.

 

Brown, Laura. “Gender and Artistic Expression in Little Women (2019).” Cinema and Society, vol. 8, no. 4, 2021, pp. 112-128.

 

Green, Amy. “Feminist Themes in Greta Gerwig’s Adaptation of Little Women.” Women’s Studies Review, vol. 35, no. 2, 2020, pp. 98-114.